← All 18 theoriesAnthony Roberts, Jr.
No. 15Within 5 yearsEvidence ●●● Strong

The creator economy is a bubble.

Everyone’s a creator now, and the numbers don’t add up.

Trading follows and paying for promotion decide who gets seen, which leaves little room to just say what you think. 48.7% of U.S. creators earn under $10,000 a year; only 5.7% clear $100,000.1 Goldman Sachs counts 3% of creators worldwide as professional and expects that share to shrink, and brand deals make up about 70% of creator revenue.2

48.7%
of U.S. creators make less than $10,000 a year from their content.
Data: 2026 survey · Influencer Marketing Factory

48.7% of U.S. creators earn less than $10,000 a year from their content (The Influencer Marketing Factory).

More numbers

57%

of full-time creators earn less than a $44,000 U.S. living wage from content.3

$480B

projected size of the creator economy by 2027, up from $250B. The money grows; the paychecks don’t (global).2

2.5%

share of creators Goldman Sachs expects to be professional by 2030, down from 4% in 2022 (global).2

The other side

The creator economy keeps growing overall, and a middle tier earning $10,000 to $100,000 a year is expanding.

45.6%

of U.S. creators earn $10,000 to $100,000 a year, a growing middle class. The Influencer Marketing Factory ↗

51.5%

of creators saw their earnings grow in 2025. The Influencer Marketing Factory ↗

Why Anthony still holds this view

Growth is concentrated among creators who are already established. Nearly half still earn under $10,000.

For marketers

Most creators can’t live on content, so mid-size creators are affordable and motivated partners. Paid placement keeps crowding out free, unpaid reach.

For you

Notice when a post is paid placement, and weigh it that way.

Related theories

Sources

  1. The Influencer Marketing Factory, survey of 1,000 U.S. creators
  2. Goldman Sachs Research, creator economy reports, 2023 and 2025 (global)
  3. Influencer Marketing Hub, 2025 Creator Earnings Report

Take the quiz and vote on this theory